Focus

The increasing use of independent contractors signals a potentially harmful return to former work arrangements

This month's cover feature, "An unfair market," focuses on contractors who intentionally misclassify workers as independent contractors, which, in turn, gives them an unfair competitive advantage and results in lost revenue for local, state and federal governments.

But consider, too, the harm done by those who classify independent contractors correctly.

Fortune magazine reports research conducted by labor economists Lawrence Katz and Alan Krueger shows legal alternative work arrangements, which include independent contractors, expanded 50 percent from 2005-15.

According to an article published in Fortune, Jeffrey Pfeffer, the Thomas D. Dee II professor of organizational behavior at Stanford University's Graduate School of Business, these "new" work arrangements are, in fact, old.

Pfeffer writes: "Today's use of independent contractors paid on a piece-rate system represents a return to the work arrangements of 140 years ago, not some new managerial innovation."

Pfeffer notes the idea of providing benefits and pensions for employees sprung from the idea of "welfare capitalism," which sought to impede the growth of unionization and government regulation. But as companies realized they were incurring costs their competitors were not, more returned to the older model of employment.

"Companies started to cut employees loose quite a while ago," he writes. "What we see today is just a continuation of a trend to treat people as human resources, as assets to be acquired and discarded according to the return for doing so."

But, he argues, cutting employees loose to reduce costs takes a significant toll on the human psyche. Social support in workplaces can reduce stress and improve physical and mental well-being among employees.

Pfeffer writes: "The employment arrangements disrupt an old and important reason for working—the opportunity to be part of a group. … What's missing from the current labor market is a sense of humanity."

Ambika Puniani Bailey is editor of Professional Roofing and NRCA's vice president of communications and production.

More From This Issue

  • Exemplary service

    Since the mid-1990s, a majority of commerce in the U.S. economy has shifted from hard goods to information and services. As a result, customers now expect instant service, such as receiving itemized invoices for purchases at grocery stores. Taking a cue from supermarkets, contractors can provide exemplary service to their clients by implementing methods to quickly provide repair invoices.

  • A roofing wonder

    Visitors to the Science Pyramid at Denver Botanic Gardens can explore the world of plants and ecosystems using interactive technology. The unique 3,800-square-foot space was designed to mimic nature and includes a complex roof system installed by United Materials LLC, Denver, that encompasses hexagonal concrete-composite panels resembling honeycombs across 16 roof planes in varying slopes and degrees.

  • A better way

    Roofing contractors often must adapt to changes in the roofing industry while continuing to install quality roof systems safely, on time and on budget. Those who can adapt quickly usually are the most successful. Understanding best practices for business management—including business literacy, people management, business growth and leadership development—can help roofing contractors adapt to changes and increase profitability within their companies.

;